Autism and Borderline: When Two Worlds Collide
- Gert de Heus
- Aug 24
- 5 min read
Autism (ASD) and borderline personality disorder (BPD) may seem far-fetched at first glance. Yet, clinicians and patients frequently report overlap and comorbidity. This blog explores how these two conditions can influence each other, the challenges this presents, and the perspectives available.
Although figures vary, clinical experience indicates that true comorbidity between ASD and BPD is not very common. Sometimes ASD is overdiagnosed in people with emotional dysregulation, or vice versa. However, there are patients who have been carefully diagnosed with both disorders, with symptoms that fit into both domains.
Diagnostic challenges
Several factors play a role in the diagnosis of ASD and BPD:
The age of onset: ASD shows early developmental behavior, BPD often manifests from adolescence onwards.
Symptom overlap: emotional dysregulation, difficulty with social cues, and identity instability occur in both.
Masking and externalizing: Especially women with ASD may exhibit social masking, while BPD patients sometimes claim ASD traits to find external explanations.
A careful history, including child development and emotional patterns, is crucial to make the correct assessment.
Different perspectives
The clinical perspective
Psychiatrist A rarely sees genuine comorbidity but warns of both under- and overdiagnosis of BPD. Psychotherapist B emphasizes that symptoms always occur in degrees and recommends standardized assessment tools (e.g., PID-5, RAADS).
The research perspective
Researchers in the HiTOP movement advocate for symptom profiling instead of dichotomous labels. They investigate overlap in emotional dysregulation and interpersonal difficulties.
The patient perspective
Many people with BPD temporarily identify with an ASD label through online communities, often to find an explanation for relationship problems. Autistic patients sometimes experience frustration when BPD is recognized too late, because they are not given a framework for emotional instability.
Experience story
Sophie (27) was diagnosed with ASD at age 12. She learned to manage sensory sensitivities, but struggled with severe mood swings and separation anxiety in her teenage years. It wasn't until she was 20 that her GP discussed the possibility of BPD when Sophie recognized herself in the description of unstable relationships and self-image.
In therapy, she discovered that some outbursts stemmed from sensory overload, others from fear of rejection. By acknowledging both diagnoses, she was able to work on structuring her daily routine and her emotional self-awareness. She is now taking social skills training for ASD and dialectical behavioral therapy for BPD.
Treatment implications
An integrated treatment plan might look like this:
Psycho-education about ASD and BPD, so that the patient develops symptom recognition.
Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) focuses on emotion regulation and interpersonal effectiveness.
Autism Adaptations: Visual Schedules, Predictable Sessions, and Sensory Breaks
Family or network guidance to reduce misunderstandings and frustrations.
A multidisciplinary team consisting of a psychiatrist, psychotherapist, and occupational therapist can offer the best outcome. The combination of ASD and BPD remains a complex and sometimes puzzling area. True comorbidity is possible but rare, while overlapping symptoms often leads to diagnostic confusion. By integrating multiple perspectives and sharing a personal story like Sophie's, treatment becomes more in-depth and personalized. Ultimately, it's about recognition, understanding, and a treatment plan that recognizes all aspects of a person's unique profile.
Focus on Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD)
Perhaps a bit off-topic, but what is Borderline Personality Disorder and what you absolutely need to know about it? We'll delve deeper. The term borderline was coined in 1938 by psychiatrist Adolph Stern. He used it to describe people who were on the borderline between neurosis and psychosis.
We now know that borderline personality disorder (BPD) is a complex and multifaceted condition that defies simple categorization. This is precisely why there are many misunderstandings and prejudices about people with BPD. There is no standard type. The diagnosis is based on nine criteria, of which at least five must be present. Within this group, there is considerable variation in how the symptoms manifest.
Intense fear of abandonment - Going to enormous lengths to avoid real or imagined abandonment.
Unstable and intense relationships - Relationships often swing between idealization (putting someone on a pedestal) and devaluation (rejecting someone completely).
Identity disorder - A highly variable or unclear self-image, for example, uncertainty about who you are or what you want.
Impulsiveness in at least two harmful areas. For example, spending, sex, drugs, reckless driving, or binge eating.
Recurrent suicidal behavior or self-harm - This may include cutting, burning, or other forms of self-harm, often as a way of coping with emotions.
Severe Mood Swings - Intense, rapidly changing moods that usually last from several hours to a few days.
Chronic Emptiness - A deep, persistent feeling of meaninglessness or inner emptiness.
Intense anger or difficulty controlling anger - For example, frequent tantrums, sarcasm, bitterness, or physical aggression.
Paranoid thoughts or dissociation under stress - Temporary paranoid ideas or feelings of being detached from yourself or reality, especially in stressful situations.
Although women are more likely to be diagnosed, men can also have borderline personality disorder. It's possible that women are more likely to seek help, while men with BPD more often exhibit behavioral problems and are therefore sometimes given a different diagnosis, such as antisocial personality disorder.
People with BPD experience intense emotions and rapid mood swings. This can sometimes seem unpredictable, but that doesn't mean they're unreliable. They're often surprised by their own feelings.
Relationships with someone with BPD can be challenging, but certainly not impossible. People with borderline personality disorder are often highly sensitive and long for connection. Understanding and good communication are essential. What sometimes seems like attention-seeking is often an expression of deep emotional pain. Fear of abandonment or rejection can lead to behavior that is difficult for outsiders to understand.
Self-harm and impulsive behavior are common in people with BPD. This doesn't always mean there's a death wish, but it can be risky. Professional help is important in such cases. People with BPD are usually not dangerous to others. However, relationships can be intense due to the intensity of their emotions, which sometimes leads to conflict.
Genetics plays a role, but BPD usually develops from a combination of genetics and traumatic experiences, such as childhood trauma. With the right treatment, such as psychotherapy, people with BPD can learn to manage their emotions and behavior. In about half of the cases, the diagnosis eventually disappears completely.
Theoretical Framework Overview of studies on autism and borderline personality disorder
1. Comorbidity and Overlap between Autism Spectrum and Borderline Personality Disorder: State of the Art
Dell'Osso L, Cremone IM, Nardi B, et al. examined clinical and epidemiological data and conclude that people with BPD more often exhibit subclinical autistic traits and that borderline features emerge in a portion of the ASD population. They advocate for integrated diagnosis and treatment that recognizes both spectrums.
2. The overlap between autistic spectrum conditions and borderline personality disorder
Dudas RB, Lovejoy C, Cassidy S, Allison C, Smith P, and Baron-Cohen S conducted a large-scale PLoS ONE study and found that adults with BPD have significantly higher scores on autism questionnaires, and conversely, higher BPD traits in ASD groups. This finding underscores the clinical relevance of symptom overlap and the importance of thorough evaluation.
3. The interface of autism and (borderline) personality disorder
In a guest editorial in The British Journal of Psychiatry, Zavlis O. and Tyrer P. discuss how personality disorders may be inherent to the autistic spectrum. They integrate the issues of misdiagnosis and comorbidity by proposing that personality disorders are dimensionally part of neurodivergence, while ASD features are not necessarily present in all PDs.
Comments